Religious Bias Suit in COVID Vaccine Mandate Case On January 7, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reversed and remanded a district court’s dismissal of a plaintiff’s Title VII religious bias suit—holding the case was sufficient to survive a motion to dismiss at the pleading stage. The matter, Barnett v. Inova Health Care Services , provides key insights and reminders for employers attempting to balance workplace policies with employees’ religious beliefs. The matter concerned Inova’s COVID-19 vaccine policy. Inova’s policy mandated all employees receive the COVID-19 vaccine unless they had a religious or medical exemption. Barnett, the plaintiff, was a registered nurse and devout Christian. Inova first rolled out its COVID vaccine policy in 2021. At that time, Barnett requested a medical exemption based on lactation concerns but also objected on religious grounds. Inova granted Barnett’s exemption request. According to Barnett, later that year Inova revised its policy and required all employees with an existing vaccine exemption reapply under the new criteria. Barnett claims Inova then required all employees requesting a religious exception complete a questionnaire about their particular religious beliefs applicable to the COVID vaccine. The questionnaire—which Barnett attached to her lawsuit—requested the following […]

By : Markus McDowell